Time for another thrilling episode of: Fleck Cove's theories!
Ok, so i have a theory: King Jupiter is the Pilgrim.
"Wait- he was killed!" or so we think....
I've had this theory since reading EE. and i like asking a certain question....
so:
"do you have to know a person/rabbit to be that person/rabbit?"
take, for instance, this: I'm myself. but do i know myself? have i met myself?
no. i haven't met myself. [at least i don't think i have...]
So, could Pilgrim be King Jupiter? or have i been daydreaming too much? [no, never such things...]
-Fleck Cove!
I think it would be a bit similar if Blackgaard were to come back to Odyssey, even though he's a REALLY cool character, (and I would love to see him return) I don't think it would be conducive to a good plot.
I rather hope it's not, I read the "Dragons in our Midst" series and the author made several characters die and come back to life several times.
In fact one character died and came back not once, not twice, but three times!!!! 😡😡😡
We're gonna stick with the Pilgrim is Massie...Plus it said the Pilgrim was a friend of the family for generations!!
We still think it's Massie!!!!!
#ThePilgrimIsMassie
Okay, I like the idea and where it is coming from. But for this to be true certain things would have to be true, such as
Helmer said he saw King Jupiter die, as well as Wilfred. If your theory is true, Jupiter would had to have had a brother that looked very much like him that no one but Jupiter and his family knew about. This could be true, and if King Jupiter really didn't die, Garten knew it. Therefore he would be saying this to drive fear into the hiding rabbits. This is very hard to believe though that he would be hiding a brother.
Since the last doesn't meet ends, lets say that he almost died, like Smalls perhaps. Tell me if I'm wrong, but Garten didn't think that Morbin was really gonna kill him. Maybe Morbin didn't totally kill him. If so, Garten could have used True Blue to heal him. But for this Garten would have to have pity upon his brother which is unlikely to me.
Jupiter would have to go into hiding for thirteen years. I'm not saying it's impossible, Lady Glen did it. He would be able to defend himself. But personally I think word would get back to Morbin.
I'm not saying it's impossible for it to happen. S.D. Smith is amazing at what he does and how he portrays it. Personally, I would love if that was true. I would love it for Emma, Smalls, Winslow, and Whitbie. Great theory!